Government Healthcare—Analysis of Pros & Cons (2022)

Government healthcare refers to government funding of healthcare services via direct payments to doctors, hospitals, and other providers. In the U.S. healthcare system, medical professionals are not employed by the government. Instead, they provide medical and health services privately and are reimbursed by the government for these services, in much the same way that insurance companies reimburse them.

An example of a successful U.S. government healthcare program is Medicare, established in 1965 to provide health insurance for people aged 65 and over or who meet other criteria such as disability.

For many years, the U.S. was the only industrialized country in the world, democratic or non-democratic, without universal healthcare for all citizens provided by government-funded coverage. But in 2009, that changed. Here's everything that happened and why it matters still today.

50 Million Uninsured Americans in 2009

In mid-2009, Congress worked to reform U.S. healthcare insurance coverage, which at that time left more than 50 million men, women, and children uninsured and without access to adequate medical and health services.

This deficit was due to the fact that healthcare coverage for all people, except for some low-income children and those covered by Medicare, was provided only by insurance companies and other private-sector corporations. This made it inaccessible for many Americans.

Private company insurers proved ineffective at controlling costs and providing inclusive care, some actively working to exclude as many people from healthcare coverage as possible.

(Video) Study Proves Government-Run Healthcare Is Better Than Private Insurance

Explained Ezra Klein for The Washington Post: "The private insurance market is a mess. It's supposed to cover the sick and instead competes to insure the well. It employs platoons of adjusters whose sole job is to get out of paying for needed health care services that members thought were covered," (Klein 2009).

In fact, multi-million bonuses were even awarded annually to top healthcare executives as an incentive to deny coverage to policyholders.

As a result, in the United States pre-2009, more than eight in ten of individuals uninsured were from families living 400% below the Federal Poverty Level. Non-white populations were also disproportionately uninsured; Hispanics had an uninsured rate of 19% and Blacks had a rate of 11% though people of color only made up 43% of the population. Finally, 86% of uninsured individuals were adults not classified as elderly.

In 2007, Slate reported, "The current system is increasingly inaccessible to many poor and lower-middle-class people ... those lucky enough to have coverage are paying steadily more and/or receiving steadily fewer benefits," (Noah 2007).

This widespread issue led to a reform campaign begun by the Democratic party and supported by the president.

Reform Legislation

In mid-2009, things got heated when several coalitions of Congressional Democrats crafted competing healthcare insurance reform legislation. Republicans did not contribute much substantive healthcare reform legislation in 2009.

(Video) CESG2020 "AI, Analytics, and Efficient Healthcare Delivery" Government Healthcare Panel

President Obama voiced support for universal healthcare coverage for all Americans, which would be provided by selecting among various coverage options, including an option for government-funded healthcare or a public plan option.

However, the President stayed safely on the political sidelines at first, forcing Congressional clashes, confusion, and setbacks in delivering on his campaign promise to "make available a new national health plan to all Americans."

Healthcare Packages Under Consideration

Most Democrats in Congress, like the president, supported universal healthcare coverage for all Americans offered through various insurance providers and many coverage options. Many saw a low-cost, government-funded healthcare option as important to include.

Under the multi-option scenario, Americans satisfied with their present insurance could opt to keep their coverage. Americans dissatisfied or without coverage could opt for government-funded coverage.

As this idea spread, Republicans complained that the free-market competition offered by a lower-cost public-sector plan would cause private-sector insurance companies to cut their services, lose customers, and inhibit profitability to the extent that many would be forced to go entirely out of business.

Many progressive liberals and Democrats believed strongly that the only fair, just U.S. healthcare delivery system would be a single-payer system, such as Medicare, in which only low-cost, government-funded healthcare coverage is provided to all Americans on an equal basis. Here's how the public responded to the debate.

(Video) Pros & Cons at Private or Public universities|| study Masters in Germany||

Americans Favored a Public Plan Option

According to HuffPost journalist Sam Stein, the majority of people were in support of public healthcare options: "... 76 percent of respondents said it was either 'extremely' or 'quite' important to 'give people a choice of both a public plan administered by the federal government and a private plan for their health insurance,'" (Stein 2009).

Likewise, a New York Times/CBS News poll found that, "The national telephone survey, which was conducted from June 12 to 16, found that 72 percent of those questioned supported a government-administered insurance plan—something like Medicare for those under 65—that would compete for customers with private insurers. Twenty percent said they were opposed," (Sack and Connelly 2009).

History of Government Healthcare

2009 was not the first year that government healthcare was talked about, and Obama was far from the first president to push for it; past presidents had proposed the idea decades before and taken steps in this direction. Democrat Harry Truman, for example, was the first U.S. President to urge Congress to legislate government healthcare coverage for all Americans.

According to Healthcare Reform in America by Michael Kronenfield, President Franklin Roosevelt intended for Social Security to also incorporate healthcare coverage for seniors, but shied away for fear of alienating the American Medical Association.

In 1965, President Lyndon Johnson signed into law the Medicare program, which is a single-payer, government healthcare plan. After signing the bill, President Johnson issued the first Medicare card to former President Harry Truman.

In 1993, President Bill Clinton appointed his wife, well-versed attorney Hillary Clinton, to head a commission charged with forging a massive reform of U.S. healthcare. After major political missteps by the Clintons and an effective, fear-mongering campaign by Republicans, the Clinton healthcare reform package was dead by Fall 1994. The Clinton administration never tried again to overhaul healthcare, and Republican President George Bush was ideologically opposed to all forms of government-funded social services.

(Video) Swachh Bharat Mission- evaluation Healthcare Budget 2022 UPSC Current Affairs analysis Public Policy

Again in 2008, healthcare reform was a top campaign issue among Democratic presidential candidates. Presidential candidate Barack Obama promised that he would "make available a new national health plan to all Americans, including the self-employed and small businesses, to buy affordable health coverage that is similar to the plan available to members of Congress."

Pros of Government Healthcare

Iconic American consumer advocateRalph Nader summed up the positives of government-funded healthcarefrom the patient's perspective:

  • Free choice of doctor and hospital;
  • No bills, no co-pays, no deductibles;
  • No exclusions forpre-existing conditions; you are insured from the day you are born;
  • No bankruptcies due tomedical bills;
  • No deaths due to lack of health insurance;
  • Cheaper. Simpler. More affordable;
  • Everybody in. Nobody out;
  • Save taxpayers billions a year in bloated corporate administrative and executive compensation costs, (Nader 2009).

Other important positives of government-funded healthcare include:

  • 47 millions Americans lackedhealthcare insurancecoverage as of the 2008 presidential campaign season. Soaring unemployment since then caused the ranks of the uninsured to swell past 50 million in mid-2009. Mercifully, government-funded healthcare provided access tomedical servicesfor all uninsured, and lower costs of government healthcare caused insurance coverage to be significantly more accessible to millions of individuals and businesses.
  • Doctors and other medical professionals can now focuson patient care and no longer need to spend hundreds of wasted hours annually dealing with insurance companies. Patients, too, no longer need to fritter inordinate amounts of time haggling with insurance companies.

Cons of Government Healthcare

Conservatives and libertarians generally oppose U.S. government healthcare mainly because they don't believe that it's a proper role of government to provide social services to private citizens. Instead, conservatives believe thathealthcare coverageshould continue to be provided solely by private-sector, for-profit insurance corporations, or possibly by non-profit entities.

In 2009, a handful of Congressional Republicans suggested that perhaps the uninsured could obtain limited medical services via avoucher system and tax credits for low-income families. Conservatives also contended that lower-cost government healthcare would impose too great of acompetitive advantageagainst for-profit insurers.

TheWall Street Journal argued: "In reality, equal competition between a public plan and private plans would be impossible. The public plan would inexorably crowd out private plans, leading to a single-payer system," (Harrington 2009).

(Video) Is it good to study BSc Public health/ health and social care in UK|| Scope|| Jobs|| Malayalam

From the patient's perspective, the negatives of government-funded healthcare include:

  • A decrease in flexibility for patients to freely choose from a vast cornucopia of drugs,treatment options, and surgical procedures offered today by higher-priced doctors and hospitals.
  • Fewer potential doctors may opt to enter the medical profession due to decreased opportunities for high compensation. Fewer doctors, coupled with skyrocketing demand for doctors, could eventually lead to a shortage of medical professionals and to longer waiting periods for appointments.

Healthcare Today

In 2010, the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA), often called Obamacare, was signed into law by President Obama. This act provides provisions that make healthcare more affordable such as tax credits to low-income families, expanded Medicaid coverage, and made more types of health insurance available to uninsured consumers at different prices and levels of protection. Government standards have been put in place to ensure that all health insurance covers a set of essential benefits. Medical history and pre-existing conditions are no longer legitimate grounds for denying coverage to anyone.

Sources

FAQs

What are the pros and cons of a healthcare plan? ›

What are the Pros and Cons of a Healthcare Plan? Pros of health care plan are Cashless hospitalization, Network Hospitals, No Claim bonuses, Add-ons, or Riders, Financial security, Affordable premium. One of the main cons of having a health care plan is the cost, Pre-Existing Exclusion, Waiting Period, Co-Pay.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of government providing free healthcare? ›

However, this essay so far discussed the disadvantages of government providing free health care for their citizens. The disadvantages are poor service, lack of ownership on health and limitation of free medicine program. On the other hand, the advantages are government assistance, health infrastructure and taxation.

Why is it important for the government to provide health care? ›

Public health promotes the welfare of the entire population, ensures its security and protects it from the spread of infectious disease and environmental hazards, and helps to ensure access to safe and quality care to benefit the population.

What can government do to improve people's health? ›

For example, the government can impose tax on junk foods. Also, there are other ways like, building parks and stadium that encourage the people to exercise. In addition to that, the government can also promote health by forecasting programs and advertisement about health on tv and radio.

What are the cons of healthcare plan? ›

The primary disadvantage to getting health insurance is the cost, as the different health insurance plans can warrant higher premiums relative to many factors including the status of your health, your age, your lifestyle, etc..

What are pros and cons? ›

The pros and cons of something are its advantages and disadvantages, which you consider carefully so that you can make a sensible decision.

Why government hospitals are better? ›

They provide individual care. One can have a private ward to take care of the patient 24*7. The hospitals have well-maintained hygiene. The cost of treatment at government hospitals is relatively less than in private hospitals.

What are the advantages of healthcare? ›

Health insurance protects you from unexpected, high medical costs. You pay less for covered in-network health care, even before you meet your deductible. You get free preventive care, like vaccines, screenings, and some check-ups, even before you meet your deductible.

How does the government impact healthcare? ›

Because of its influence, the government has played an important role in promoting the use of preventive services. It also has promoted increased recognition of how disease prevention contributes to healthcare efficiency and cost-savings. Originally, Medicare was not allowed to authorize primary preventive services.

Is healthcare the government's responsibility? ›

Conclusion: Government's responsibility to protect and advance the interests of society includes the delivery of high-quality health care.

Does the government control healthcare? ›

The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services is the federal government's principal agency involved with health care services. The states cofund and administer their CHIP and Medicaid programs according to federal regulations.

How can local government improve health in the community? ›

How Local Governments Can Advance Health Equity through Their Built Environments
  1. Advancing inclusive resident engagement and collaboration. ...
  2. Prioritizing resources for communities experiencing health inequities. ...
  3. Formalizing staffing roles and structures and training staff to listen.
Jul 14, 2020

What are the steps taken by government to provide healthcare for all? ›

Different ways through which the government can take steps to provide healthcare for all: (i) Establishing public healthcare at zonal level. (ii) Setting up low cost government hospitals. (iii) Health insurance for basic treatment. (iv) Provision of clean drinking water and steps to check pollution.

How does public health affect daily life? ›

Public health protects and improves communities by preventing epidemics and the spread of disease; promoting healthy lifestyles for children and families; protecting against hazards in homes, work, communities and the environment; ensuring high-quality health-care services; safeguarding and improving the quality of the ...

What is the importance of health? ›

Having good health is directly related to leading a productive life. The functionality of the body is interconnected between various organs. Keeping the organs healthy is essential for proper functioning. As health is the state of physical, mental and social well-being, having good health is important.

What are the 10 essential health care benefits? ›

What Are the 10 Essential Health Benefits?
  • Ambulatory patient services. ...
  • Emergency services. ...
  • Hospitalization. ...
  • Pregnancy, maternity, and newborn care. ...
  • Mental health and substance use disorder services. ...
  • Prescription drugs. ...
  • Rehabilitative and habilitative services and devices. ...
  • Laboratory services.

Is healthcare a right or a privilege? ›

Article 25 of the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights lists medical care as a basic human right.

What are some examples of pros and cons? ›

Example Sentences
  • There are pros and cons to having children.
  • I'm weighing the pros and cons of moving to another state.
  • The pros and cons of using a laptop for work are debatable.
  • The pros and cons of taking a day off work are clear.
  • There are pros and cons to every decision we make in life.

How do you talk about pros and cons? ›

How to Discuss the Pros and Cons of Something | English Grammar with ...

How do you write pros and cons? ›

First, write the decision that you have to make at the top of a two-column grid. Label one side "Pros" and the other "Cons." Then, list all of the possible positive consequences of the decision in the pros column, and all the negative effects in the cons column.

What are the pros of the US healthcare system? ›

  • Most preemptive cancer screening. ...
  • Highest rate of cancer survival. ...
  • Best treatment of chronic disease. ...
  • Most identification and treatment of psychological disease. ...
  • Most advanced equipment per capita. ...
  • Highest pay attracts the best doctors. ...
  • Most advanced research. ...
  • If you have the money, US health care is nonpareil.
Mar 10, 2010

What are the pros and cons of the Canada's healthcare system? ›

Pros & Cons of Canada's Free Health Care
  • Pro: Universal Access to Health Care for All. ...
  • Con: Priority Assessment Means Some Must Wait Longer. ...
  • Pro: Landmark Public Education Programs to Reduce Costs. ...
  • Con: Critics Argue Fee Limits are Out of Sync with Cost of Living. ...
  • Pro: Comprehensive Coverage for Veterans in Elder Years.

What is the advantage of health insurance? ›

The main purpose of medical insurance is to receive the best medical care without any strain on your finances. Health insurance plans offer protection against high medical costs. It covers hospitalization expenses, day care procedures, domiciliary expenses, and ambulance charges, besides many others.

What are the strengths of the healthcare system? ›

It has a large and well-trained health workforce, a wide range of high-quality medical specialists as well as secondary and tertiary institutions, a robust health sector research program and, for selected services, among the best medical outcomes in the world.

Videos

1. The Harsh TOXIC Reality Of Indian Medical Field | Anuj Pachhel
(Anuj Pachhel)
2. Pakistan Budget Pros and Cons | detail analysis of tax imposed on public.
(Zia Ul Rasheed)
3. Explore Government Medical Colleges In Abroad | Study MBBS from Uzbekistan
(collegeclue)
4. Research Basics: Systematic Reviews and Meta-analysis in Public Health
(GRID Council)
5. Healthcare & Medical Industry: Government Purchasing Analysis
(BidPrime)
6. Palantir Intrinsic Value Business Analysis (Government Platform w/ Competitive Software Advantages)
(My Financial Focus)

Top Articles

Latest Posts

Article information

Author: Rob Wisoky

Last Updated: 12/03/2022

Views: 5604

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (68 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Rob Wisoky

Birthday: 1994-09-30

Address: 5789 Michel Vista, West Domenic, OR 80464-9452

Phone: +97313824072371

Job: Education Orchestrator

Hobby: Lockpicking, Crocheting, Baton twirling, Video gaming, Jogging, Whittling, Model building

Introduction: My name is Rob Wisoky, I am a smiling, helpful, encouraging, zealous, energetic, faithful, fantastic person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.